Which Staten Island neighborhoods have the highest home values?

New York’s Staten Island — According to recent data, where you live on Staten Island may have a significant impact on the value of your house.

The Staten Island Advance/SILive.com determined which communities had the highest and lowest property prices by analyzing recently released data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2023 American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year Estimates.

The median property value for owner-occupied units across Staten Island was $658,500, although there were notable area variations, with some neighborhoods having values that were almost 75% higher than others.

The typical home value in Tottenville’s 10307 ZIP code was $799,100, almost 21.4% more than the borough-wide average.

The typical property value in Mariners Harbor’s 10303 ZIP code was $457,600, or 30.5% less than the borough-wide average.

The U.S. Census Bureau’s 2023 ACS 5-year Estimates for the median house value in each Staten Island ZIP code are shown here.

10301 (Randall Manor, Sunnyside, Grymes Hill, New Brighton, Tompkinsville, St. George, and a portion of Livingston)

• 
  $657,000
  

10302 (Elm Park and Port Richmond)

• 
  $586,300
  

Mariners Harbor, 10303

• 
  $457,600
  

10304 (parts of Todt Hill, Dongan Hills, Emerson Hill, Stapleton, Clifton, and Concord)

• 
  $659,900
  

Grasmere, Ocean Breeze, Rosebank, Shore Acres, South Beach, Arrochar, Fort Wadsworth, and a portion of Dongan Hills are all located in 10305.

• 
  $627,200
  

10306 (Egbertville, Richmond, Oakwood, Grant City, Midland Beach, New Dorp, and a portion of Dongan Hills)

• 
  $675,400
  

(Tottenville) 10307

• 
  $799,100
  

Great Kills and Bay Terrace, 10308

• 
  $648,800
  

10309 (Woodrow, Charleston, Rossville, Prince’s Bay, Richmond Valley, and Pleasant Plains)

• 
  $745,500
  

10310 (a portion of Livingston and West Brighton)

• 
  $623,300
  

(Annadale, Greenridge, Huguenot, Arden Heights, and Eltingville) 10312

• 
  $698,900
  

10314 (Willowbrook, Travis, Westerleigh, Bulls Head, Castleton Corners, Graniteville, and Meiers Corners)

• 
  $665,500
  

More Data Stories:

• As U.S. home ownership rates rise, Staten Island sees shift towards renters, new data shows

• NYC has most expensive homes per square foot of any U.S. city, data shows

• Deadliest cars on the road: Did your vehicle make the list?

• This graph shows rising rent prices of Staten Island apartments, by number of bedrooms

• Rent prices spiked nearly 60% in these Staten Island neighborhoods over past decade, data shows

Note: Every piece of content is rigorously reviewed by our team of experienced writers and editors to ensure its accuracy. Our writers use credible sources and adhere to strict fact-checking protocols to verify all claims and data before publication. If an error is identified, we promptly correct it and strive for transparency in all updates, feel free to reach out to us via email. We appreciate your trust and support!